So, let’s begin. The garage roller is a part of the door, that makes the movement of this door easier and smoother. When you open and close the door, there is no noise — and that’s exactly what door rollers do.

The reasons why you do want to replace your old rollers with some new ones can vary. Maybe, your old rollers break — when this happens, opening and closing the door becomes really rough.

The 5 Best Garage Door Rollers:

  1. F&T Garage Door Steel Rollers 12 Pack  – the best garage door rollers
  2. Dura-Bilt Nylon Garage Door Roller
  3. 2 Inch 13 Ball Nylon Garage Door Rollers
  4. Dura-Lift 6200Z Nylon Garage Door Roller
  5. Dura-Lift Ultra-Life MAX
 Product namePhotoView on Amazon
1. F&T Garage Door Steel Rollers 12 Pack1. F&T Garage Door Steel Rollers 12 PackView on Amazon
2. Dura-Bilt Nylon Garage Door Roller2. Dura-Bilt Nylon Garage Door RollerView on Amazon
3. 2 Inch 13 Ball Nylon Garage Door Rollers3. 2 Inch 13 Ball Nylon Garage Door RollersView on Amazon
4. Dura-Lift 6200Z Nylon Garage Door Roller4. Dura-Lift 6200Z Nylon Garage Door RollerView on Amazon
5. Dura-Lift Ultra-Life MAX5. Dura-Lift Ultra-Life MAXView on Amazon

REVIEWS YOU CAN TRUST 

We strive to always give you genuine, accurate information. To do this, all of mechanicguides.com reviews are based on market research, expert input, and practical experience. This knowledge comes from a team of automotive journalists and an independent mechanic, Steve “Whip” Whipple who has 11 years of experience in the auto industry. For more information, see here.

Or maybe, the noise becomes a problem (like when the ball bearings aren’t lubricated as needed and make small holes in the metal). Or you just want to DIY something (and well, why not begin with a garage door?). These reasons don’t matter.

The main thing you have to know is: the replacement of a door roller isn’t a problem at all. Basically, you’ll have to open the door, to fix it with a clamp to release the door from the opener and remove the rollers to insert the new ones. After that, you’ll have to re-install the door.

I simplified the process and skipped some steps, but you’ve got the idea. Now let’s talk about the differences among the different types of door rollers. Spoiler: it’s quite simple, too.

So, there are two things you must consider: the size and the material. As for the garage door rollers sizes, it’s easy as that — you’ll have to remove the roller (or open the door if you can’t remove it) and measure the width of its head. The most common sizes are ¾, 1 ¾, 2 ¾ inches.

The material is another, more interesting question. The thing is, the majority of the rollers are now made of two materials: steel and nylon. The differences are quite clear:

  • nylon rollers are much, much quieter. They simply minimize the vibration thus reducing the noise level
  • nylon rollers are not as durable as the steel ones. The thing is, steel is harder, so they will work for 20 years or so, while nylon rollers may work for 10-15 years (the figures aren’t 100% accurate, but they are close to reality)


So, the choice hasn’t become more clear, right? What I can say here is that the score of the game “Garage door rollers: nylon vs steel” is 1:1. However, I prefer the nylon garage door rollers because they are really much quieter.

Let’s finally do what you’re here for — review the top-5 rollers. There are 4 nylon rollers and 1 steel roller here, the garage door roller sizes vary from 1 ¾ to 2 ¾ and they all have one thing in common: all of them are extremely good. Let’s continue.

List of the Best Garage Door Rollers:

1. F&T Garage Door Steel Rollers 12 Pack  – the best garage door rollers

Garage Door Rollers. Steel Rollers 12 Pack
  • 10 BALL BEARINGS - VERY STRONG ROLLER
  • 4'' Zinc Plated Stem
  • WORKS WITH MOST RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL DOORS
  • 7/16" DIAMETER STEM 1-13/16" DIA. WHEEL
The very first thing for you to do: buy these two additional products: SK7103 door hinge made of steel and the WD-40 spray. The door hinge is necessary to install the rollers and the WD-40 is a great lubricant, which would extend the life of the rollers.

Now, when you are ready and prepared, let’s talk about the rollers.

They are made of steel, which means they are really strong and durable. According to the manufacturer, the tests were carried out and these tests showed that 10,000 openings and closings weren’t a problem at all. They used a 100 lb load (45kg) so the result is really good.

I’ve just said that the main problem of such rollers is that they are noisy — but it seems like I was unaware of these rollers then. The bearing balls contain 13 balls here so they are as quiet as possible. I like it.

Well, that’s basically all I can say about these steel rollers. They work smoothly and quite quietly, pardon the pun — and they are really durable. However, the nylon rollers are still quieter.

P.S. They are quite cheap, just like all the steel rollers.

2. Dura-Bilt Nylon Garage Door Roller

Sale
13 Ball Nylon Garage Door Rollers (4 Inch Stem) Sealed Bearing (10 Pack)
  • Ultra-Quiet Operation: the 13-ball Precision bearing reduces rotational friction between roller and shaft
  • Extra Quiet Rollers: reduces garage noise by up to 75 percent with a Precision 13-ball bearing and nylon roller wheels are much quieter than original equipment garage rollers
  • Ultra Lubrication: bearing lubrication groove contains Mobilgrease XHP 222 grease for enhancing bearing protection in low and high temperature applications (5F to 300F / -15C to 150C)
  • Verified Test Ratings: exceeds 10,000 door open/close cycles at 100 pound load
  • Standard Size: 4-5/8" long shaft, 7/16" thick shaft, 1-13/16" wheel diameter, 1/2" wheel shoulder, 1/2" wheel thickness
I recommend buying this Blaster lubricant together with this door roller — if you want the rollers to work literally for decades, you can’t miss it. And it works in all types of weather, both cold and hot.

What I like most is the level of noise. It’s very, very low — I mean that when you open or close the door, you can’t hear the noise at all. Just a pure perfection.

Smooth and quiet work, extremely low price, simple installation — this Dura-Bilt product can really make your garage a much more comfortable place for work.

3. 2 Inch 13 Ball Nylon Garage Door Rollers

Sale
2-Inch 13 Ball Nylon Garage Door Rollers With 4-Inch Stem (Set of 10)
  • Roller has a lubrication groove to disperse lubrication over a long period of time
  • 4-5/8" overall 4-1/8" shaft 1/2" shoulder 7/16" ( 11.09") shaft thickness
  • 1/2 inch wheel thickness 1-13/16 inch wheel Dia
The rollers with 13 balls are the best rollers in 2018. They are the quietest and the most durable ones, and this one is another typical representative of such rollers.

Typical, but very good. It’s one of those garage door rollers 1 ¾ size that can work for dozens of years, and I’m not exaggerating here — what’s more, they are also really easy-to-install so you’ll have no problems with it even if you are new to the DIY world.

I also recommend buying this isolation kit in order to maximize the results. If you haven’t ever used one of such kits, you’ll be surprised by the reduced vibrations and noise — and together with these rollers, this kit works wonders.

These rollers have longer stems, and it’s a brilliant idea because with the long stems a garage door won’t come out of the bent track if something goes wrong.

4. Dura-Lift 6200Z Nylon Garage Door Roller

Sale
DURA-LIFT Ultra-Life 2" Reinforced 6200Z Bearing Nylon Garage Door Roller and 4" Stem (10 Pack)
  • ULTRA-LIFE: reinforced 6200Z bearing with heavy-duty cage increases life of rollers up to 10x longer than original equipment rollers
  • 6200Z STANDARD BEARING: holds ball bearings in place so there is less play and friction between bearings, resulting in 10x the longevity of the roller with a cycle rating of up to 150,000 cycles
  • ULTRA-QUIET OPERATION: reduce noise by up to 75% with a 6200Z ball bearing with heavy-duty cage - much quieter and longer lasting than original equipment garage rollers
  • ULTRA LUBRICATION: bearing lubrication groove contains Mobilgrease XHP 222 grease for enhancing bearing protection in low and high temperature applications (5°F to 300°F / -15°C to 150°C)
  • VERIFIED TEST RATINGS: rated at 150,000 door open/close cycles at 110 pound load
Perfect for wooden and for steel doors, extremely quiet yet a little bit more expensive than the previous rollers — meet the 6200Z nylon roller!

If you replace your plastic or steel rollers with this product, you will be shocked. These rollers are very quiet, strong and easy to install, but I’ve already written all this stuff about the other rollers. So, what’s the difference?

This roller is extremely durable and strong. According to the test, 100,000 openings and closings aren’t a problem for this roller — just imagine, if you open and close your garage door 6 times a day, you will have to replace the roller after 45-50 years or even later!

I also love their new bearing idea. The thing is, these rollers have only 8 bearings instead of 13 — but because of the design, they are still tenfold stronger!

5. Dura-Lift Ultra-Life MAX

DURA-LIFT Ultra-Life MAX 2" Sealed 6200ZZ Bearing Nylon Garage Door Roller, 4" Stem, Pack of 10
  • LIFETIME GUARANTEE: reinforced dual-wall bearing cage, sealed 6200ZZ ball bearing plus double plating thickness on stem designed for MAX performance and ultra-life weather protection
  • DUAL-WALL BEARING CAGE: dual-walled, reinforced bearing cage provides maximum strength and lifetime durability
  • SEALED CAP: protects the 6200ZZ bearings and the high-performance Mobilgrease Grade XHP 222 grease in bearing cage, preventing dirt and grime to penetrate the bearings
  • ULTRA-LIFE MAX ROLLERS: reinforced dual-cage 6200ZZ bearing, sealed cover, and double plating not only reduces door noise up to 75% more than standard rollers, but offers lifetime operation
  • TEST RATINGS: rollers specified to perform up to 250,000 cycles at 110 lb load test
Can’t say too much here. This roller is the winner, the perfect and the best roller on the market — thanks to maximum protection, maximum performance, and more than 120,000 door cycles (enough for 60+ years).

You just have to see it with your own eyes. Be ready that you’ll have to spend a lot of money, but is it a problem if we are talking about the thing that you’ll have to replace somewhere in the 2080s?

As with every other product, here you have a choice. You can spend less and buy the steel rollers — they are still cool, but a little noisy.

You can spend a little more and solve the problem for the next 15-20 years or you can spend quite serious money and forget about the rollers for 60 years or so — I’ve tried to collect all the options here. Hope you’ve found something here.